Friday, August 26, 2016

The Bluth Disconnect

Arrested Developement is the story of a wealthy family filled with some terrible people.  The story follows the middle son as he tries to hold the family together after the father is arrested for various illegal activities.  All of the characters are so incredibly self involved that they know almost nothing about each other's lives or the real world.  The following scene shows the mother Lucille talking on the phone driving when someone pulls out in front of her and the choice words they have for each other.
https://youtu.be/SkpeB7etL9A
 What really makes this scene special is the fact that later on it is revealed that the other driver is her husband who is on the run from the authorities.  Its very ironic, considering the fact that she was talking about how much she missed him on the phone. The superiority theory functions in that our laughter is to deride others.  We feel superior due to some shortcoming of a character.  The "failing or defect" we see in this scene is how disconnected the Bluth parents are.(Monro)  Lucille speaks highly of her husband now that he's missing, though she does next to nothing to find him.  Her husband George isn't much better, escaping prison and doing nothing to contact his family in his own self interest. One can also feel superior because of their uncivil exchange. They are both quick to respond in pretty targeted ways to each other. The incongruity theory is what I believe holds the real key to this scene.  It suggests that humor comes from the "abrupt intrusion into the attitude of something."(Monro) In other words, it takes something we have expectations about and will take a sharp turn from that in an unexpected but enjoyable way.  Lucille's entire character consists of this.  One would expect her to play the part of the loving mother and wife, which she seems to think she does.  However, though unknowingly, she and her husband have such an interaction. Through this moment we have now received new insights into Lucille's character.

3 comments:

  1. Superiority theory seems more plausible in the case of obnoxious and problematic characters like the Bluth family. One ambiguity of course is whether we laugh because other people demonstrate superiority, which we share (as in their ridiculous superiority), or if we laugh at them feeling superior. It's hard for me to feel satisfaction and feeling superior to people who are so obviously impervious to shame.

    Does the name of your blog pun on the character from the show?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Its not as much a pun as a reference or just a quote. Its the time the Mom said she loved all of her kids equally but then it immediately cuts to that and explains a lot of moments when she seemed completely ambivalent towards him. One of the times she seems happiest is laughing and joking while he's in the hospital.

      Delete
    2. Oh of course! I forgot about that scene.

      Delete